| 司法裁判中“不应当知道”运用研究 |
点此下载全文 |
| 引用本文:彭中礼,谭卓婕.司法裁判中“不应当知道”运用研究[J].湖南大学学报社会科学版,2025,(4):140-148 |
| 摘要点击次数: 220 |
| 全文下载次数: 209 |
|
|
| 中文摘要:“不应当知道”概念是司法裁判中推理和论证的重要对象,在司法中的理解和运用呈现出鲜明特点。实证研究发现,司法裁判中运用“不应当知道”在整体上仍存在界定、认定、证明和论证等方面问题。对此,应通过类型化思维厘定内涵,运用推定方法联结客观标准与主观状态,并通过法律方法加强论证说理。实证研究和理论探究表明,在司法裁判中确定“不应当知道”的词义,既需要法律对概念做严格界定,也应当运用适恰的法律方法进行逻辑推理。 |
| 中文关键词:不应当知道 司法裁判 法律方法 |
| |
| A Study on the Application of“Should Not Have Known”in Judicial Adjudication |
|
|
| Abstract:The concept of “should not have known” is a significant object of reasoning and argumentation in judicial adjudication, and its understanding and application in the judicial context exhibit distinct characteristics. Empirical studies have revealed that the application of “should not have known” in judicial adjudication still has problems in the aspects such as definitions, determinations, proofs, and argumentations on the whole. For this case, we should define the connotation through typed thinking, use the constructive method to link the objective standard with “should not have known”, and strengthen the argumentation and reasoning through legal methods. Empirical research and theoretical investigation show that the definition of “should not have known” in judicial judgments requires strict definitions of the concept by law and logical reasoning by appropriate legal methods. |
| keywords:should not have known judicial adjudication legal approach |
| 查看全文 查看/发表评论 下载pdf阅读器 |